Make New Crayons (From Broken Pieces!) | Mitzy Makes It
Mitzy Makes It! • Reuse + Create

Make New Crayons From Broken Crayon Bits

A simple, parent-friendly craft that turns broken crayons into brand-new colors. Great for rainy days, classroom prep, and “we have a million crayon crumbs” moments.

⏱️ Time: 30–60 min
🔥 Heat: adult-only
🧼 Cleanup: easy-ish
🎨 Result: custom colors!
Jump to Printable

Mitzy Tip 💡

Peel wrappers first (or warm crayons in your hands for a minute so the paper slips off easier).

Safety Note 🔥

Melting wax gets hot. Adults handle the oven + removing molds. Keep little hands at a safe distance.

What You’ll Need

Keep it simple. The magic is in the crumbs.

Broken crayons
Silicone mold
Baking sheet
Oven mitts
Foil / parchment
Adult supervision

Color Ideas 🎨

Try: “all blues” for ocean crayons, “sunset mix” (red/orange/yellow), or layer two colors for a marbled look.

Common Oops 😅

Wrappers left on = messy melt. Chunks not packed down = bubbles/holes. Fix: re-melt 2–3 minutes and cool again.

Parent Checklist

Use this as your “I’m ready” list before the oven step.

Kid Helper Jobs 👧🧒

Sorting colors, peeling wrappers, filling molds, naming the new colors. (Adults do heat + oven.)

Step-by-Step Instructions

Tap each step to expand (works great on mobile, no scripts needed).

1 Sort & Peel

Sort crayons by color family (or go wild and mix!). Peel off wrappers and break crayons into small bits.

  • Smaller pieces melt faster and more evenly.
  • Tip: Warm crayons in your hands to loosen wrappers.
Sorting and peeled crayon pieces
2 Fill the Mold

Place the silicone mold on a baking sheet. Fill each shape with crayon bits and gently press down.

  • Pack pieces in to reduce air gaps.
  • For a marbled look: layer two colors instead of mixing.
Finished homemade crayons
3 Melt (Adult Step)

Preheat oven to ~250°F (120°C). Bake for 10–15 minutes until fully melted. Ovens vary—keep an eye on it.

  • Ventilate the kitchen (wax smell can be strong).
  • Do not put in the oven with paper wrappers on.
Finished homemade crayons
4 Cool & Pop Out

Remove tray carefully. Let molds cool on the counter, then chill in the fridge 10–20 minutes for easy release.

  • When cool, bend the silicone to pop crayons out.
  • If crayons feel soft, chill longer before removing.
Finished homemade crayons
5 Label & Store

Store in a jar or pencil box. Bonus fun: name your new colors.

  • “Giggle Grape”
  • “Robot Raspberry”
  • “Queeky Sunshine”
Finished homemade crayons

Matching Printable

Click Print / Save as PDF above. In the print dialog choose Save as PDF. (This print view hides everything except the sheet below.)

Make New Crayons From Broken Pieces
Mitzy Makes It! • Parent Craft Sheet
Date: ____________

Steps (quick version)

  1. Peel wrappers + break crayons into small bits.
  2. Fill silicone mold (on a baking sheet).
  3. Melt at ~250°F (120°C) for 10–15 minutes (adult step).
  4. Cool, then fridge 10–20 minutes.
  5. Pop out + store + name your colors!

Checklist

☐ Wrappers removed
☐ Mold on baking sheet
☐ Ventilation on
☐ Pieces packed in
☐ Cooled before popping out

My new crayon color names

Safety: Adults handle heat + oven. Let wax cool completely before touching.